Sears Home Services
appointment lookup logoAppointment Lookup
telephone logo419-558-4893
RepairHome WarrantyHome ImprovementClean & MaintainShop PartsResource Center
RepairHome WarrantyHome ImprovementClean & MaintainShop PartsResource Center
appointment lookup logoAppointment Lookup

Table of Contents

Understanding Home Warranties

Is a Home Warranty Worth the Investment?

What Does a Home Warranty Cover?

How a Home Warranty Works

Considerations When Choosing a Home Warranty

Alternatives to Home Warranties

  1. Resource Center
  2. Protect

Is the Cost of a Home Warranty Worth It in 2024?

9 min readUpdated Jun. 03, 2024Kimberly HillegassKitchen Appliances
Young couple researching home warranty options

Home warranties, often referred to as homeowner warranties, offer a vital safety net for homeowners by covering the repair and replacement costs of major household systems and appliances, such as heating and cooling systems, electrical setups, and kitchen appliances. But, a key question often arises: Is the cost of a home warranty really worth it in 2024? In an environment where the prices of everything, including appliance repairs, are rising, unexpected repairs can be costly. Understanding the nuances and benefits of home warranties can equip you with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision.


  • Home warranties provide financial protection by covering the costs of repairing or replacing major home systems and appliances.
  • Evaluating your home's age, your financial situation, and specific circumstances can help determine if a home warranty is a valuable investment for you.
  • Alternatives to home warranties, such as self-insurance or manufacturer's extended warranties, offer different benefits and might better suit your needs.

Understanding Home Warranties

A home warranty is a service agreement that offers coverage for the repair or replacement of major household systems and appliances. It acts as a financial safety net designed to shield homeowners from unexpected repair costs. But how can you determine whether the cost of the warranty justifies the expense?

One of the primary advantages of a home warranty is the financial protection it provides. When a covered appliance or system fails due to regular use, the home warranty company will arrange for a qualified technician to repair or replace the item. This arrangement can save homeowners from potentially high repair or replacement costs.

Homeowner warranties also offer convenience. Instead of searching for a reliable contractor when something breaks, homeowners can simply contact their warranty provider for prompt service. This is especially beneficial for those unfamiliar with local service providers or who prefer the services of a trusted company.

It's important to differentiate between home insurance and a home warranty. While home insurance typically covers damage from unexpected events like fires, theft, or natural disasters, a home warranty covers everyday systems and appliances. Many homeowners choose both to ensure comprehensive coverage.

Is a Home Warranty Worth the Investment?

Determining if a home warranty is worth the investment depends on several factors. Although it provides valuable coverage for unexpected repairs, it may not be necessary or cost-effective for everyone.

Age of Home and Appliances

Older homes and the appliances within them are more likely to require repairs as they age beyond their expected lifespan. A home warranty can be a strategic investment in these cases, covering costs that might otherwise pose a significant financial burden. For homeowners in older properties, this peace of mind can be particularly valuable, especially if the condition of systems like HVAC, plumbing, or electrical are uncertain.

Financial Situation

A home warranty may be particularly advantageous for those with limited savings or those who prefer their monthly budgets to remain consistent. The warranty acts as a buffer against large, unexpected repair bills that can strain finances. For individuals or families who prioritize financial predictability, the regular cost of a warranty may be preferable to facing sudden, high expenses.

Specific Circumstances

Certain scenarios make a home warranty especially beneficial. For instance, if your home appliances are nearing the end of their warranty period or you are planning to sell your home, a home warranty can provide an attractive selling point to potential buyers. It reassures them that they are protected from major repair expenses, which can expedite the sale and possibly increase the home’s market value.

Ultimately, a home warranty can reduce stress by protecting against unexpected repair costs. However, it’s essential to carefully evaluate your unique circumstances to decide if the benefits justify the expense. Consider not only the current state of your home and financial stability but also your long-term housing plans and the reliability of the warranty provider.

What Does a Home Warranty Cover?

A home warranty provides coverage for the repair or replacement of major home systems and appliances due to normal wear and tear. Here are some commonly covered items:

  • Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems
  • Electrical systems
  • Plumbing systems
  • Water heaters
  • Kitchen appliances such as refrigerators, ovens, and dishwashers
  • Laundry appliances including washers and dryers
  • Garage door openers
  • Ceiling fans

It’s important to understand that there are coverage limits and exclusions within a home warranty. For instance, issues due to pre-existing conditions or improper maintenance might not be covered. Always review the terms and conditions of the warranty you're considering carefully.

Home warranty providers also offer optional add-ons and upgrades to customize the coverage to better suit your needs. These options may include coverage for extra appliances, pools, spas, or even roof leaks. Assess your lifestyle and home needs when selecting these options.

For many homeowners, the benefits of a home warranty—providing financial protection and peace of mind—are compelling. It allows you to focus on enjoying your home, rather than worrying about potential repairs.

How a Home Warranty Works

Understanding how a home warranty works can help when weighing its value against its cost. Here’s an expanded explanation of the typical process:

Claim Filing

When a covered item breaks down, the first step is to contact the home warranty company to file a claim. Prompt reporting ensures the issue is addressed quickly. The warranty company will then review the claim to confirm that the item is covered and the breakdown is due to normal wear and tear. If the claim is approved, the company will proceed with the next steps to resolve the issue.


Responsibilities under a home warranty are twofold: homeowners must regularly maintain the covered items to ensure they remain in good working order; the warranty provider, on the other hand, is responsible for arranging and covering the costs of repairs or replacements as stipulated in the contract. This partnership is essential for the smooth functioning of the warranty service. Homeowners need to be aware that neglect or improper maintenance can lead to denials of service requests.

Repair and Replacement Timeline

The timeline for repairs and replacements can vary depending on the warranty provider and the specific circumstances of the breakdown. Most home warranty companies aim to address and resolve claims within a few days, but delays can occur, especially if parts need to be ordered or if the required repairs are complex. Some warranty providers may have a network of preferred contractors or technicians who are typically dispatched to handle the repairs, ensuring quality and timeliness.

Understanding the detailed process of claim filing, the shared responsibilities, and the typical timelines for repairs and replacements can help you effectively assess whether a home warranty is the right choice for your household.

Considerations When Choosing a Home Warranty

Choosing the right home warranty requires careful consideration of several key factors. Here’s a more detailed look at what to consider:

Research and Comparison

Before deciding on a home warranty provider, conduct thorough research and compare different companies. Evaluate factors such as the cost of the warranty, coverage limits, and any additional fees that may apply. Consider the range of items each warranty covers and compare these details across different providers to find the best match for your needs.

Terms and Conditions

Understanding the terms and conditions of a home warranty is essential before committing to a contract. Pay close attention to what exactly is covered and what is excluded. Note any deductibles, service call fees, or coverage limitations that could affect your decision. It's important to read the fine print to avoid surprises when you need to use the warranty.

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews can offer valuable insights into a company's service quality and reliability. Look for patterns or common issues among the reviews to get a realistic sense of what to expect. Positive and negative reviews can help gauge the likelihood of satisfaction with the company’s service and responsiveness.

Additional Perks

When comparing home warranty plans, consider those that offer extra benefits, which can provide significant additional value. For example, plans like the Sears Protect Home Warranty not only cover typical repairs and replacements but also include perks such as at least $600 worth of HVAC tune-ups annually, discounts on water filters and appliance parts, reduced prices on repairs for non-covered appliances, and home improvement discounts. These added benefits can enhance savings and improve home maintenance, making some warranties more attractive than others based on the extras they provide.

By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision and select a home warranty that best suits your needs.

Alternatives to Home Warranties

Exploring alternatives to home warranties is a practical approach if you're looking for different ways to protect your home and appliances. Here are some viable options:


Instead of opting for a home warranty, you might consider setting aside a dedicated savings fund to cover unexpected repair or replacement costs. This self-insurance method gives you full control over your funds and ensures that you're not bound by coverage limitations or deductibles. It allows for greater flexibility and may be a cost-effective solution if you are capable of managing a reserve fund efficiently.

Manufacturer's Extended Warranties

For new appliances, extended warranties offered by manufacturers can be an excellent alternative to home warranties. These extended warranties typically provide coverage that goes beyond what the standard warranty offers, extending the protection period and sometimes covering additional issues that might arise after the standard warranty expires.

Home Maintenance Services

Another alternative is subscribing to home maintenance services. Some companies offer service plans that include regular maintenance checks and repairs for a fixed annual or monthly fee. This can be a particularly attractive option for maintaining HVAC systems, plumbing, and electrical systems, ensuring they are in good working condition and potentially preventing expensive breakdowns.

Credit Card Benefits

Check if your credit card offers extended warranty protections. Many credit cards extend the manufacturer’s warranty on items purchased with the card, providing an additional layer of protection without extra cost. This benefit often goes unnoticed but can be a simple way to extend the life of your appliances and systems.

By considering these alternatives, you can determine what best meets your specific needs and financial situation, offering protection for your home while possibly saving money compared to traditional home warranties.

At Sears Home Services, we understand the importance of keeping your home running smoothly. With our comprehensive range of home repair and maintenance services, including versatile home warranty options, we're equipped to help protect your home against the unexpected. Contact us today to explore how we can support your home maintenance needs and ensure your home remains in top condition.

Was this information helpful?

Protect Kitchen Appliances Resources

Acquiring a Home Warranty: Your Step-by-Step Guide in 2024

Discover how to get a home warranty with Sears Home Services.

3 min readJun. 06Kitchen Appliances
Home Warranty appliance plan

Find out the important details about home and appliance warranties at Sears Home Services.

7 min readMay. 31Kitchen Appliances
A focused homeowner examines his kitchen sink, checking for any garbage disposal issues in a bright, modern kitchen setting.

Master garbage disposal repair with our expert tips and step-by-step troubleshooting guide.

6 min readJun. 13Kitchen Appliances
Why Are Sears Techs the Best in the Industry?

Learn what makes Sears Technicians the best in the appliance repair and home services industry.

4 min readJun. 13Kitchen Appliances